Season launch · Fall · Halloween · Holiday 2026

That Ball Was Fair And New York Knows It Tee, Pete Alonso Signature Baseball Fan T-Shirt

4.5K+ bought in past month

$19.99

4.8(116)
in Sports
Standard Shipping Arrives Nov 9 – 12

Typically delivered in 3–6 business days (US)

  1. Nov 6 Order placed
  2. Nov 7 – 8 Order ships
  3. Nov 9 – 12 Delivered
Clear selection
  • Total: $0.00
Size guide · How it fits

Unisex T-Shirt · Gildan 5000

Unisex classic fit — true to size. Size up for a looser look.

SizeLengthChest (flat)
S2818
M2920
L3022
XL3124
2XL3226
3XL3328
4XL3430
5XL3532

All measurements in inches. Chest width is laid flat (half chest). View all size charts

Buy more, save more

  • 2 items 5% OFF
  • 3 items 10% OFF
  • 4 items 15% OFF
  • 5 items 20% OFF

Arrives by Nov 9 – 12 if you order today. Hooray!

Real customer photos

Alicia
Georgann
Kathleen

See more reviews

Guaranteed safe checkout
Description

That Ball Was Fair And New York Knows It Tee

This black cotton graphic fan shirt is built for New York baseball supporters and features Pete Alonso signature styling in high-contrast orange and white typography.

shirt

Soft Cotton Blank

Crafted from breathable 100% cotton to provide lasting comfort during long innings at the ballpark.

shield

Durable Print

High-contrast orange and white lettering stays crisp and vibrant through regular wear and machine washing.

star

Signature Details

Includes distinct Pete Alonso signature styling that celebrates iconic moments in New York baseball history.

user

Unisex Fit

Features a classic crewneck collar and standard regular fit suitable for all baseball fans.

Fan apparel features and design details

The That Ball Was Fair shirt captures the intensity of memorable ballpark moments with bold orange and white lettering set against a solid black cotton canvas. Designed for everyday wear or game day rallies, this piece honors the signature of Pete Alonso and speaks directly to dedicated supporters of New York baseball.

Ideal game day and gifting occasions

Stadium visits and home gamesSports bar watch partiesBaseball season openersNew York Mets fan gear collectionsBaseball fan gift givingTailgate gatherings
Material
100% cotton
Color
Black with orange and white print
Collar
Crewneck
Fit
Regular unisex fit

Frequently Asked Questions

How does this Pete Alonso signature shirt fit?

This tee features a standard unisex regular fit. Order your usual size for a comfortable everyday feel, or size up if you prefer a looser, relaxed look.

How should I wash and dry the graphic?

Machine wash inside out with cold water and similar colors. Tumble dry on low heat or hang dry to preserve the print quality and fabric softness.

Will the printed text crack or fade quickly?

No, the design utilizes durable screen printing techniques designed to resist cracking and fading when washed according to care instructions.

Is this a baseball quote shirt suitable for gifting?

Yes, this graphic tee makes a thoughtful gift for birthdays, holidays, or any occasion for New York baseball fans and supporters of Pete Alonso.

Upgrade your game day wardrobe

Get your That Ball Was Fair And New York Knows It Tee today and wear your team loyalty proudly all season long.

What our customers say

Real reviews from verified Etsy shoppers.

4.8 (73,575)340K+ salesStar Seller
See all reviews
Etsy
★★★★★

Loved this T-shirt! The quality of the T-shirt is really good, it's not a cheap, thin T-shirt. I got black sparkles for the design and I love it.…

Disney Family Shirt

Alicia · Apr 27, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Perfect. Just as pictured and described.

Disney Family Shirt

Georgann · Apr 26, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

I love my shirt!! It is sooo pretty!!!

Faith Cross Shirt

Kathleen · Apr 26, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

I absolutely love this shirt. It's very soft and well made. I highly recommend this shop.

Schools Out For Summer Shirt

B. Wilson · Apr 24, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Beautiful shirt. Fast service. Love the color.

Faith Cross Shirt

Dale · Apr 23, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Super nice gift! Delivery took a while but the result is great.

Super Daddio Shirt

Nicole · Apr 23, 2025