Season launch · Fall · Halloween · Holiday 2026

What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for shirt

3.5K+ bought in past month

Original price was: $27.99.Current price is: $19.99.Save 29%

4.7(492)
in T-shirt
Standard Shipping Arrives Nov 5 – 8

Typically delivered in 3–6 business days (US)

  1. Nov 2 Order placed
  2. Nov 3 – 4 Order ships
  3. Nov 5 – 8 Delivered
Clear selection
  • Total: $0.00
Size guide · How it fits

Unisex T-Shirt · Gildan 5000

Unisex classic fit — true to size. Size up for a looser look.

SizeLengthChest (flat)
S2818
M2920
L3022
XL3124
2XL3226
3XL3328
4XL3430
5XL3532

All measurements in inches. Chest width is laid flat (half chest). View all size charts

Buy more, save more

  • 2 items 5% OFF
  • 3 items 10% OFF
  • 4 items 15% OFF
  • 5 items 20% OFF

Arrives by Nov 5 – 8 if you order today. Hooray!

Real customer photos

Alicia
Georgann
Kathleen

See more reviews

Guaranteed safe checkout
Description

This fan-made Jay Buhner shirt displays the provocative question, 'What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for,' capturing a memorable moment in Seattle Mariners history. It is an ideal conversation starter for baseball enthusiasts who appreciate sports trivia and dry humor. Wear this tee to game day or gift it to a friend who loves nostalgic baseball references.

Highlights

  • Features bold text referencing the infamous Jay Buhner trade
  • Ideal for Seattle Mariners fans and baseball history buffs
  • Perfect casual wear for game days or social gatherings
  • Great novelty gift for sports enthusiasts with a sense of humor
What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for shirt
tank top
What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for shirt
long sleeve
What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for shirt
sweater
What the hell did you trade Jay Buhner for shirt
hoodie

Find Your Fit

Check the size chart for exact measurements before you order.

Made to Order

Each item is made when you order it. US delivery typically takes 3–6 business days (production + shipping); see shipping details. Colors may vary slightly between your screen and the finished product.

FAQ

How long does delivery take?

US delivery typically takes 3–6 business days, including production time for this made-to-order item.

Is this suitable as a gift?

Yes, it makes a thoughtful present for baseball fans, particularly those who follow Seattle Mariners history or enjoy sports-themed jokes.

What our customers say

Real reviews from verified Etsy shoppers.

4.8 (73,575)340K+ salesStar Seller
See all reviews
Etsy
★★★★★

Loved this T-shirt! The quality of the T-shirt is really good, it's not a cheap, thin T-shirt. I got black sparkles for the design and I love it.…

Disney Family Shirt

Alicia · Apr 27, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Perfect. Just as pictured and described.

Disney Family Shirt

Georgann · Apr 26, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

I love my shirt!! It is sooo pretty!!!

Faith Cross Shirt

Kathleen · Apr 26, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

I absolutely love this shirt. It's very soft and well made. I highly recommend this shop.

Schools Out For Summer Shirt

B. Wilson · Apr 24, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Beautiful shirt. Fast service. Love the color.

Faith Cross Shirt

Dale · Apr 23, 2025

Etsy
★★★★★

Super nice gift! Delivery took a while but the result is great.

Super Daddio Shirt

Nicole · Apr 23, 2025